Designing a new type of receipt in the iMessage environment as an attempt to mitigate the negative effects of read receipts

Contributions:
Designer: sketched, wire-framed, & created the hi-fi prototype
Researcher: user interviews, data analysis

Duration:
5 weeks

Context:
Project for Master's Program
Team of 2: 1 other UX Designer

Tools Used:
Figma, Canva, Procreate

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Project Overview

Inspired by the implicated social rules around read receipts in messaging, my teammate and I designed a new type of receipt for the iMessage architecture called the “Glanced” receipt. This feature allows the user to preview a new message without sending a read receipt right away, while still communicating some information to the sender of the message.

Problem

Solution

We came up with a new "Glanced" receipt in iMessage for users with read receipts on. This modifications allows users to preview an incoming message without triggering a read receipt right away. We found in our research that users already purposefully preview messages without sending a read receipt for numerous reasons, and designed specifically with this behavior in mind. Previewing an incoming message sends a "Glanced" receipt to the sender until the user decides to fully read and engage with a message. We played with different visual representations and the constraints around the receipt without disrupting the existing iMessage systems.

Research

Literature Review

We did a literature review on 10 published research articles around read receipts, their impact on the communication and the emotional well-being of users.

Remote Survey

We sent out a short-survey about participants online communication habits and attitudes around read receipts. We got responses from 24 participants between the ages 20-35, with all of the participants using online communication for work, school, and/or social life.

The most revealing insight was that most of the participants found ways to get around sending a read receipt but still read the message.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Semi-structured Interviews

We conducted 5 user interviews with iMessage users, 3 users with read receipts on and 2 off. Our small interview pool allowed us to review each interview and find the pain points. we created user personas to solidify our research findings.

User Personas & Empathy Maps

I created user personas and empathy maps based on all our interview transcripts and findings to guide our design. The two types of arching personas were one user very comfortable with read-receipts while another who is unnerved by them.

Research Takeaways

Design Process

Sketches

I sketched the frames below to give us an idea before we jumped into digital prototyping. The sketches were based on our research and initial brainstorming sessions.

Sketches Feedback

We showed the sketches to some of our interview participants, as well as my industry mentor Chris Myles, to get feedback before we moved to a higher fidelity. Due to the time constraints of the project, we chose to get feedback early in the design cycle to be able to have the best end prototype.

Our initial idea included a timer starting with the glancing action, which would be indicated by the color of the glanced notification. Our participants were worried that a timer might add to the anxieties around communication. We found the feedback extremely valuable, and strayed away from the idea of a timer attached to this receipt.

User Flows

I created User Flows of our two main uses cases to guide our design: 1- Glancing at a message and 2- receiving a Glanced receipt.

Prototype

We created a high-fidelity prototype on Figma adhering to the iMessage visual language. We wanted to show how the different visual representations might look in the real environment. This fidelity also allowed us to try a dynamic notification.

Retrospective



Another design cycle would have allowed me and my teammate to explore the design and its implications better. A diary study with participants about using this feature over the course of a few weeks would have also been interesting.

I learned that it is challenging to design when people's emotions and social cues are involved, but found myself really interested in this design space for the future. I myself began the project with an avid distaste for read receipts, but turned on read-receipts for the sake of the project. At first it was nerve-wrecking, but months after the project has ended, I still have my read-receipts on. I have a newfound appreciation for the clarity and accountability read-receipts bring to a conversation.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Example of text field